Cookie consent in France: what the CNIL requires
In short: the CNIL fined Fnac Darty €7 million for an app that kept sending data after the user clicked “Continue without accepting”. The rule is not in the GDPR: it is article 82 of the French Data Protection Act, and its exemptions cover only trackers strictly necessary to deliver the service. Personalisation and commercial targeting are not exempt. The fine also came with an order to prove compliance, under a €10,000 per day penalty for late compliance.
What happened
On 22 October 2026 the CNIL, the French data protection authority, fined Fnac Darty Participations et Services €6 million and Fnac Direct €1 million — €7 million in total — for the rules applicable to trackers. The decision was published on 29 October.
The facts are narrow, and that is exactly what makes them instructive: after a user clicked “Continue without accepting”, the app continued to send data.
The company had reacted quickly. The Android application was corrected on 19 September 2023, four days after the complaint filed by the association noyb and six months before the CNIL’s inspection. That was not enough: at the March 2024 inspection, requests were still going out after a refusal. The group states it removed the tool in December 2024, on Android and iOS, and replaced it in January 2025.

Why a refusal must genuinely stop the tracking
French rules on trackers come from article 82 of the loi Informatique et Libertés, which is separate from the GDPR: the GDPR frames personal data handling in general, article 82 frames consent to the deposit and reading of trackers.
The exemptions in article 82 cover only trackers strictly necessary to provide the service: securing a session, remembering a shopping cart, ensuring the technical operation of a service. The CNIL states that personalisation and commercial targeting are not covered by these exemptions. A refusal that still allows advertising or audience measurement is not a refusal.

What a small shop should copy from this case
- Test your own refusal path. Click “refuse”, then look at the network requests. If they still go out, you have the same problem as Fnac Darty, on a smaller scale.
- Check the wording of the refusal button. “Continue without accepting” must not be a back door that keeps the door open.
- Do not confuse article 82 with the GDPR. A tracker can be GDPR-compliant in its purpose and still be illegal without consent.
- Keep the proof, dated. The CNIL’s doctrine on this point dates from May 2021, when about twenty digital players were already put on notice on the same subject.
- Treat an old fix as suspect. A correction deployed six months before the inspection did not prevent the CNIL from finding the behaviour still present.
Questions
Is a cookie banner enough to be compliant?
No. What matters is what happens after the refusal. A banner that collects a refusal, while the code keeps sending data, is the exact behaviour that led to this fine.
Which trackers do not require consent in France?
Only those strictly necessary to provide the service, under article 82 of the loi Informatique et Libertés: session security, shopping cart, technical operation. Personalisation and commercial targeting are excluded.
What is the size of the risk?
The Fnac Darty case came to €7 million, plus an injunction with a €10,000 per day penalty to prove the new tool collects valid consent. The CNIL had already acted on this point in 2021.
Sources
- CNIL — sanction against Fnac Darty on cookies: cnil.fr
- noyb — decision against Fnac Darty: noyb.eu
- Next — how the tracking worked, 7 October 2026: next.ink
- ZDNet — the CNIL’s decision on mobile trackers: zdnet.fr
Full French analysis, including the technical detail of the requests observed: Amende CNIL cookies : 7 millions d’euros pour un refus que l’app ignorait.