Normandie Digital

L'actualité du web, du référencement et de l'IA, expliquée pour les TPE et PME.

🇫🇷 FR

NIS2 for small organisations: who is in scope, and what the CNIL just fined

NIS2 for small organisations: who is in scope, and what the CNIL just fined

In short: on 9 November 2026 the CNIL announced ten sanctions against French local authorities and one public body, between €3,000 and €20,000 each, for security failures — not for a hack. Administrators without a second factor, shared accounts, supplier access left permanently open, logs no one reads. The same failures exist in a lot of small organisations, and the NIS2 directive, whose French transposition is under way, is about to make them expensive.

What the CNIL sanctioned

The inspections launched in 2025 on the IT security of municipalities have now produced results: ten simplified sanctions against local authorities and one public body, announced on 9 November 2026. The fines range from €3,000 to €20,000, the legal ceiling for that kind of procedure.

They sanction breaches of article 32 of the GDPR, the security obligation, and in several cases the absence of a data protection impact assessment before launching risky processing.

None of the cases involved a sophisticated attack. The CNIL describes access failures: administrator accounts without multi-factor authentication, supplier access kept open permanently, shared accounts, logs collected but never exploited, weak passwords. The kind of configuration that is never noticed until someone else notices it.

Why the amount is not the real cost

The simplified procedure, created in 2022 for legally straightforward cases, caps the fine at €20,000 when the organisation’s turnover is below €50 million, and €100,000 above that. Ordinary GDPR enforcement allows up to 4 % of worldwide turnover for the most serious breaches.

So the €3,000 to €20,000 bracket is a deliberate simplification, not the measure of the risk. And a detail that goes largely unnoticed: in these simplified procedures, the sanctioned organisation is not named.

A civil servant at the back of a town hall office, seen from behind, enabling a second authentication factor on a screen, riso illustration in pink and amber on a cream background.

The trend behind the decision

The CNIL had already sanctioned private companies in 2025 and 2026 for similar security failures. The perimeter is widening, from large organisations to any structure handling personal data.

NIS2: what changes in France

The NIS2 directive, whose French transposition is under way according to ANSSI, will put security requirements on several thousand entities across 18 sectors, including local authorities. Where the CNIL sanctions a failure in data protection, NIS2 adds obligations on the security of the information system itself, and its own enforcement regime.

For a small organisation, the useful way to read this is not “am I in scope?” but “would I pass an inspection on access rights?”. That is what was sanctioned, and it is independent of NIS2’s entry into force.

An IT supplier seen in profile unplugging a network cable in a server rack while an employee stands by, riso illustration in pink and amber on a cream background.

Five checks that map to the failures observed

  1. Multi-factor authentication on every administrator account, without exception, including internal tools.
  2. Supplier and freelancer access with an end date. Permanent access is what was found, repeatedly.
  3. Individual accounts. A shared account is an account where no one is responsible and nothing is traceable.
  4. Read the logs you already collect. Collecting them is not monitoring them.
  5. An impact assessment before a risky processing operation, which the CNIL sanctioned separately in several of these cases.

Questions

Is this a French problem only?

The sanctions come from the CNIL, so they are French. The security failures described — shared accounts, permanently open supplier access, unread logs — are not specific to France, and article 32 of the GDPR applies in every member state.

Do small organisations fall under NIS2?

NIS2 covers several thousand entities across 18 sectors in France, according to ANSSI, including local authorities. A small organisation should not wait for its own scope decision: the failures sanctioned above are already breaches of the GDPR’s security obligation.

How much can a simplified CNIL sanction cost?

Between €3,000 and €20,000 in the November 2026 decisions, capped at €20,000 below €50 million of turnover and €100,000 above in that procedure.

Sources

Full French analysis, with the breakdown of each failure category: Amende CNIL collectivités territoriales : les failles relevées.

Raphaël Marieux Mis à jour le 11/11/2026

J'explique le web et l'IA en français, sans jargon ni pub.

Tous ses articles